Mecklenburg County, North Carolina

Char-Meck School System Breakup?

November 17, 2026 · By James Higgins

CMS_Breakup

Breaking up is hard to do, but it’s a needed step in the right direction.

This week NC Representative David Willis spoke of the ongoing investigations of our local school system and called for recall elections of all 9 school board members. He also called for breaking up CMS, which is not a new topic in Mecklenburg, having been bandied about for quite a few years.

I think these are both meaningful steps toward school systems that are more in line with the values held by the citizens of this county. The handling of the corruption we were seeing from the superintendent, the subsequent clearing of her name only to ultimately fire her for what appeared to be personal disputes over who was allowed to be the most corrupt, was a circus act with no entertainment value. It was a pure waste of taxpayer money which further eroded the public trust in an institution already low on the county trust ladder.

CMS in it’s current form is massive, stretching from Davidson to Ballantyne, Steele Creek to Sugar Creek, and Mountain Island to Mint Hill.

The sheer size and span have raised calls to break up the district during inclement weather, days when icy streets in one corner of the county shut down 180+ schools across the area. The tax input disparity has also been a driving factor for calls to break up CMS. Taxpayers on the edge of the county watching a higher share of their taxes paying for schools well away from their kids’ stomping grounds has long been a source of frustration. Watching an entitled superintendent spend hundreds of thousands for sketchy training programs put on by her friends have not helped soothe those concerns.

No one can honestly say that CMS is currently serving all 140,000 students well. That is not to say they have ill intent or aren’t trying. CMS board members, teachers, administrators, facility and IT staff work hard to provide the best education they are able to. This is a leadership problem, not a manufactured destruction of the system from within. It does not appear to be getting better at the top. I can’t say a recall election on every board member is truly justified, but I can’t say it isn’t either. Whether that effort moves forward, I hope that the elected school board members take their charge more seriously going forward. I also hope to see more concerned parents and community members run for these seats in the future.

Should Libertarians back recalls of all sitting CMS School Board members?

Maybe. We fully support the public having means to hold their elected officials accountable, and outside of arrest for broken laws, a recall is the strongest statement that the public can make to show an elected person that they have lost the trust of the electorate. Whether they deserve to be recalled is not really in play yet because there is no current legal method to trigger a recall election.

Because of this, I think Libertarians should strongly back any efforts to enact legal means for voters to trigger recall elections. Until we have that tool in the toolbox, it is a moot point.

Should Libertarians push for the breakup of CMS into several smaller districts? I believe we should, for several reasons. The obvious ones being the disparate areas of the county already desiring a breakup and the rampant corruption we’re all seeing.

Clearly one large district is not working out and the draw of the office to command such a large budget is bringing in the wrong sorts of people.

Smaller districts would bring decisions and funding for those decisions closer to home and bring parents across the entire county closer to the makers of decisions for their children’s educations.

Either way, I think Libertarians are winning the long game as the blatant problems and corruption are making our case for putting parents back in control of their own children. We’ll be watching closely as this continues to unfold.

← All articles

Comments

Any logged-in account can comment (including pending membership). Times are Eastern (US).

Log in to leave a comment.

No comments yet — be the first.